vantanews

Chapter 10: The Plea

Lucas called me on a Tuesday morning.

"Fitch contacted Reeves," he said.

"Your father wants to negotiate."

I was at my desk at work.

I set down my coffee.

"What changed?" I said.

"Doyle's records.

The superseding indictment added four counts the original didn't have.

And Reeves told Fitch last week that she intends to call your mother as the first witness at trial." Lucas paused.

"Your father doesn't want your mother on that stand."

"Because she'll be credible."

"Because she'll be devastating," Lucas said.

"Eleven years, Victoria.

She has everything."

I looked out my office window.

February in Savannah.

The trees were bare and the sky was the color of old pewter.

"What are the terms?" I said.

"Still being negotiated.

But Reeves told me the framework: guilty plea on the primary fraud counts, full restitution to all forty-one families plus interest, dissolution of the foundation, five years minimum custody, five years supervised release, permanent bar from serving as an officer or director of any nonprofit or federally funded organization."

"Five years," I said.

"Minimum.

Reeves is pushing for seven.

Fitch is pushing back.

They'll land somewhere in between."

I sat with that for a moment.

"The forty-one families," I said.

"Full restitution."

"Plus interest.

Every family made whole."

I thought about Dr.

Cole holding that single page in the chapel.

*Forty-one families who lost their homes.* Her voice that hadn't shaken.

"Okay," I said.

"Okay meaning—"

"Okay meaning that's what matters.

The families.

The rest of it—" I stopped.

"Whatever he gets, he gets.

I'm not going to spend the next year hoping for a specific number."

Lucas was quiet for a moment.

"Reeves will want a victim impact statement from you.

You don't have to provide one.

But she'll ask."

"I'll think about it," I said.

I did think about it.

For three weeks I thought about it.

I started writing it twice and stopped both times.

Not because I didn't have things to say, but because I kept finding that what I wanted to say was not about punishment.

It was about the forty-one families.

It was about my mother carrying eleven years alone.

It was about Brandon showing up to a veterans' housing office on three consecutive Saturdays without telling anyone.

In the end, I submitted four paragraphs.

I described what I had witnessed in the chapel.

I described Dr.

Cole holding up that page.

I described what my mother had said to me when I asked her why she hadn't told me sooner: *Because you loved him.

And I didn't want to be the one who took that from you before you were ready to lose it.*

I did not ask for a specific sentence.

I asked that whatever was decided reflect the actual harm done to the actual people who had lost their homes.

The plea was entered on a Thursday in March.

I was not in the courtroom.

I had decided, after a long conversation with Lucas and a longer conversation with myself, that I did not need to be there.

I had said what I needed to say in four paragraphs.

I did not need to watch.

Lucas was there, as a representative of the original case.

He texted me when it was done.

*Guilty on all primary counts.

Six years.

Full restitution.

It's done.*

I read the message twice.

Then I put my phone in my pocket and walked down the hall to the small kitchen at my office and made a cup of tea.

My colleague Diane was in there, eating lunch and reading something on her tablet.

She looked up.

"You okay?" she said.

"Yes," I said.

"I am."

She nodded and went back to her reading.

I stood at the window with my tea and watched the street below.

A woman walking a dog.

A delivery truck double-parked.

Two teenagers on bicycles cutting through the intersection.

Six years.

Full restitution.

Forty-one families.

I thought about my father in a courtroom saying the words.

Guilty.

I thought about what his face looked like when he said them and realized I didn't need to know.

I thought about Gerald Fitch beside him and the nineteen years of representation that had ended in a federal plea agreement and decided that was consequence enough for both of them.

I finished my tea.

I went back to work.

That evening, I called my mother.

"I heard," she said when she answered.

"Are you all right?"

A pause.

"I think so.

Yes." Another pause.

"It's strange.

I've been waiting for something to end for eleven years.

And now it has.

And I don't quite know what to do with the quiet."

"You'll figure it out," I said.

"I think I will," she said.

"Eventually."

We talked for a while longer.

About the garden on her balcony, which had turned out better than she expected.

About Brandon, who had started volunteering regularly with Dr.

Cole's program and was talking about joining the board.

About small things.

Real things.

After we hung up, I sat for a moment in the quiet of the apartment I had moved into six months earlier — my own place, my own lease, my own kitchen — and I thought about what she had said.

*I don't quite know what to do with the quiet.*

I understood that.

But the quiet, I was finding, was not empty.

It was just space.

Space that had been occupied for a long time by something heavy, and now that the heavy thing was gone, the space was simply there, waiting to be filled with something chosen rather than inherited.

Lucas knocked on my door at seven.

I opened it.

He was holding two things: a bottle of wine and a very small box.

I looked at the box.

"I told you I'd ask properly," he said.

"After the arraignment."

"That was fourteen months ago," I said.

"I know.

I wanted to wait until it was actually over." He paused.

"Is it too late?"

I looked at him.

The same eyes.

The same steadiness.

The man who had spent six months building a case he didn't know how to tell me about, who had stood at an altar while my father laughed, who had handed me a business card from Commander Hayes and said *I'm sorry it happened this way, I'm not sorry I looked.*

"No," I said.

"It's not too late."

May you like

He opened the box.

I said yes before he finished the question.

Other posts