vantanews
My name is Mabel. / Chapter 5 / 7

Chapter 5: Gerald's Office and the Thing Dennis Didn't Know

The petition was filed on a Friday.

Ray called a lawyer in Columbus that same afternoon — a woman named Patricia Holt who specialized in estate and probate disputes.

He found her name through a colleague at work, called her from the driveway while I sat inside with my son doing homework at the kitchen table, trying to make the afternoon feel ordinary.

Patricia called back within the hour.

"Tell me everything," she said.

"Start from the beginning."

I told her.

The twelve years.

The pillow.

The letter.

The bank.

The beneficiary designation filed in 2018 with two witnesses and a notary.

Dennis's threat.

Gerald's call.

When I finished, she was quiet for a moment.

"The designation is solid," she said.

"Beneficiary designations on bank accounts transfer outside of probate.

They are not subject to a four-way split under intestacy law.

Dennis knows this, or Gerald has told him this, which means the undue influence angle is the only card he has."

"Can he win with it?"

"He can make noise with it.

Winning is harder.

To prove undue influence, he'd need to show that Fiona lacked mental capacity when she signed, or that you pressured or deceived her into signing.

He has neither.

What he has is a grievance." A pause.

"Do you have any documentation of your caregiving?

Medical appointments, pharmacy records, anything with your name on it as her caregiver?"

"I took her to every appointment for twelve years.

My name is on her patient records at Dr.

Hensley's office in Millbrook.

I picked up her prescriptions at the Rite Aid on Route 9.

I have receipts going back years."

"Good.

Gather everything you can." Another pause.

"Mrs.

Calloway — Mabel.

I want to be honest with you.

This will probably not go to court.

Once Dennis's attorney sees the documentation and understands what a beneficiary designation actually is, the petition will most likely be withdrawn.

But it may get uncomfortable before it gets resolved."

"How uncomfortable?"

"He may try to interview people who knew Fiona.

Neighbors.

Her doctor.

Anyone who could speak to her mental state.

He may try to find someone willing to say she seemed confused or easily influenced."

I thought about Fiona's doctor.

Dr.

Hensley had treated her for eleven years.

He had told me, more than once, that Fiona was one of the sharpest patients he had, right up until the last few months when her body gave out but her mind stayed clear.

"Let him talk to her doctor," I said.

Patricia almost smiled.

I could hear it.

"All right.

Send me everything you have.

I'll file a response to the petition by Wednesday."

I thanked her and hung up.

Ray was standing in the kitchen doorway.

He'd heard most of it.

"She sounds good," he said.

"She does."

He came in and sat down across from me at the table.

Our son had gone to his room.

The house was quiet for the first time in days.

"I want to say something," Ray said.

I waited.

"I should have been here more.

These past twelve years.

I know I was working, I know we needed the income, but —" He stopped.

Started again.

"You carried her, Mabel.

You carried her almost alone.

And I let you." He looked at his hands on the table.

"I'm sorry."

I didn't say anything right away.

"She knew," I said finally.

"That's why she did it the way she did.

She didn't put it in a will because a will goes through probate and Dennis would have had a legitimate claim.

She went to the bank herself, six years ago, and she made it airtight.

Because she knew."

Ray's eyes went red at the edges.

He pressed his lips together.

"She was something," he said.

"She was."

We sat there for a while.

The kitchen was warm.

Outside, the light was going gray and early the way it did in Ohio in January, the sky dropping close to the fields.

Then my phone buzzed on the table.

An unknown number.

I almost didn't answer.

But something made me pick it up.

"Is this Mabel Calloway?" A woman's voice.

Older.

Cautious.

"It is."

"My name is Ruth Dempsey.

I live on Route 12, just past the old grain elevator.

I was a friend of Fiona's.

We went to church together for thirty years." A pause.

"I heard what Dennis is doing.

Word travels fast in Clover Ridge." Another pause, longer this time.

"I was there.

At the bank.

In 2018.

Fiona asked me to come with her.

I was one of the witnesses."

I stood up from the table.

Ray looked at me.

"Mrs.

Dempsey," I said carefully.

"Are you willing to speak with my attorney?"

"I'm willing to do more than that," she said.

"I have a copy of the original document.

Fiona gave me one for safekeeping.

And I wrote down what she said to me that day in the parking lot afterward, because I had a feeling someday someone would need to know." Her voice was steady and certain.

"She was not confused, Mabel.

She was the clearest I'd ever seen her.

She told me exactly what she was doing and exactly why."

I pressed my hand flat against the kitchen counter to keep myself upright.

"What did she say?" I asked.

"That day in the parking lot.

What did she say?"

Ruth Dempsey took a breath.

May you like

"She said, 'Ruth, I have four children and one daughter.

And my daughter doesn't know it yet.'"

Other posts